- IDProSC - mailman.kantarainitiative.org

ID Pro SC meeting today at 1:30pm ET
by Megan Cannon 21 Nov '16

21 Nov '16

Hi, here is a suggested agenda for today's meeting: 1. Reschedule SC call? 2. Dates/Times for DG call moving forward a. Every 2 weeks b. Varied call times c. Send doodle poll 3. Scheduling working groups - want outlook invitation? 4. Non Profits on the Loose a. What are the benefits? 5. Peer2Peer at RSA 6. Megan on vacation 11/23-12/2 - Shannon to cover 7. AOB I look forward to speaking with you then! Megan Megan Cannon | Program Manager | Virtual, Inc. D: +1.781.876.6287 | M: +1.781.258.5523 mcannon(a)virtualmgmt.com<mailto:mcannon@virtualmgmt.com> virtualmgmt.com <http://www.virtualmgmt.com/> | blog.virtualmgmt.com<http://blog.virtualmgmt.com/> 401 Edgewater Place, Suite 600, Wakefield, MA, 01880 USA [cid:image002.png@01CF8A44.EB615EF0]

1 0

Returning to the matter of RSA
by Ian Glazer 18 Nov '16

18 Nov '16

One thing we could do is try and get the session approved as a P2P session. I've never tried it before. Has anyone else? -- Ian Glazer Senior Director, Identity +1 202 255 3166 @iglazer <https://twitter.com/iglazer>

3 2

Re: [Idprosc] [DG-IDPro] Call timing/frequency
by Colin Wallis 16 Nov '16

16 Nov '16

[offlist] +1 from me too. To vary the call time, I think we will need to ask folks, by email, if there are times in X timezone we absolutely avoid, so that when we go out on the Doodle poll we have 'pre-qualified out' some options that are largely unworkable. Cheers Colin On Wed, Nov 16, 2016 at 5:20 PM, Ken Dagg <kendaggtbs(a)gmail.com> wrote: > +1 Ken > > On Wed, Nov 16, 2016 at 12:19 PM Sarah Squire <sarah(a)engageidentity.com> > wrote: > >> Hey IDPros, >> >> We discussed call frequency and time on the call today. Consensus seemed >> to be that a weekly call is too frequent for this group given that >> individual working groups will also be meeting on a regular basis. >> >> Unless folks on the list object, we're looking at moving to every two >> weeks and varying the call day/time so folks who haven't been able to make >> the 9am Wednesday calls have a chance to weigh in. >> >> Sarah Squire >> Engage Identity >> http://engageidentity.com >> _______________________________________________ >> DG-IDPro mailing list >> DG-IDPro(a)kantarainitiative.org >> http://kantarainitiative.org/mailman/listinfo/dg-idpro >> > -- > Kenneth Dagg Independent Consultant Identification and Authentication > 613-825-2091 kendaggtbs(a)gmail.com > > _______________________________________________ > DG-IDPro mailing list > DG-IDPro(a)kantarainitiative.org > http://kantarainitiative.org/mailman/listinfo/dg-idpro > > -- Executive Director Kantara Initiative Inc. <https://kantarainitiative.org/> Cell: +44 (0)7490 266 778

1 0

Fwd: RSA Conference 2017 – Program Committee Results
by Colin Wallis 16 Nov '16

16 Nov '16

Hmm.. Well this suggests we will need to do some re-planning regarding the logistics of ID Pro's formation announcement. Cheers Colin ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: RSA Conference 2017 <speakers(a)rsaconference.com> Date: Wed, Nov 16, 2016 at 2:55 AM Subject: RSA Conference 2017 – Program Committee Results To: Colin Wallis <colin(a)kantarainitiative.org> Dear Colin: Thank you for your submission for RSA Conference 2017. With more than 2200 submissions, the quality and quantity of submissions for RSA Conference 2017 were at an all-time high, making the selection process extremely competitive. Unfortunately, due to the limited number of sessions for each track and the amount of sessions submitted on similar topics, many high quality submissions were not able to be incorporated into the program this year, including yours. ------------------------------ *Session Code:* 4825 *Session Title:* Rise of the Identity Professional ------------------------------ We appreciate your interest in RSA Conference 2017, and still invite you to attend the Conference. We have extended the Early Bird Registration for you so you can take advantage of our savings ($700) over the standard Full Conference registration fee. *Please register by January 29th *in order to take advantage of this rate. The registration code is: *3U7C4SFCEB*. *Submit a Peer2Peer Session (P2P): * If you are interested in facilitating a discussion on your session topic – or another topic – with a small group of your peers, submit a P2P session topic. Keep in mind a P2P session is not a presentation, but a way to connect with a smaller group and discuss important topics within the industry. Therefore, we discourage resubmitting your presentation directly as a P2P session as the Program Committee is looking for facilitated discussions. *However, the submission process takes no time at all! Our P2P Call for Facilitators is currently open and will close on Tuesday, November 22, 2016. *https://www.rsaconference.com/events/us17/speakers/ peer2peer-facilitators Again, thank you for taking the time to share your ideas. We hope to see you at the Conference! With Best Regards, The Education Management Team, Nth Degree on behalf of RSA Conference 2017 speakers(a)rsaconference.com Where the world talks security: #RSAC <https://twitter.com/search?q=%23RSAC&src=hash> EMC2, EMC, RSA and their respective logos are registered trademarks or trademarks of EMC Corporation in the United States and other countries. All other trademarks used herein are the property of their respective owners. © Copyright 2015 EMC Corporation. All rights reserved. EMC Corporation, 176 South Street, Hopkinton, MA 01748-9103 Legal Notices <http://www.emc.com/legal/legal-information.htm> | Privacy Policy <http://www.emc.com/legal/emc-corporation-privacy-statement.htm> -- Executive Director Kantara Initiative Inc. <https://kantarainitiative.org/> Cell: +44 (0)7490 266 778

1 0

A suggestion
by Ian Glazer 15 Nov '16

15 Nov '16

Gang - Giles suggested merging Membership and Services projects. Andi Hindle was game to work Services. He and Giles will work well together. I am for the merge. Others? -- Ian Glazer Senior Director, Identity +1 202 255 3166 @iglazer <https://twitter.com/iglazer>

4 3

ID Pro SC Meeting 1pm ET today
by Megan Cannon 14 Nov '16

14 Nov '16

Hi all, Here is my suggested agenda for this meeting: 1. Working groups 2. Wednesday agenda 3. Upcoming meetings - cancel Weds, Nov 23? 4. Conferences 5. AOB Please see this tracker for the working groups: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1nCkLl8GC6rwPJK_uhHaWI_9VCwBl9_F7DsO… I look forward to speaking with you soon! Thanks, Megan Megan Cannon | Program Manager | Virtual, Inc. D: +1.781.876.6287 | M: +1.781.258.5523 mcannon(a)virtualmgmt.com<mailto:mcannon@virtualmgmt.com> virtualmgmt.com <http://www.virtualmgmt.com/> | blog.virtualmgmt.com<http://blog.virtualmgmt.com/> 401 Edgewater Place, Suite 600, Wakefield, MA, 01880 USA [cid:image002.png@01CF8A44.EB615EF0]

2 1

This week's ID pro calls
by Andrew Hughes 14 Nov '16

14 Nov '16

Hi folks - I'm in the air and in a couple days of full-day workshops this week. I will be on Monday's steering committee call but will be hard pressed to make the Wednesday DG call. andrew. *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

2 1

Who's going to Consumer ID conference in Paris (a KC event)
by Colin Wallis 11 Nov '16

11 Nov '16

Folks The email thread on an ID Pro meet-up at Gartner got me thinking.. We have the above event coming up. Allan had asked me to check with Joerg if we could do a workshop as we do at EIC. The answer was a definitive 'no'.... seems that space and time are issues on this one. But I was at the OIX UK quarterly workshop yesterday and a couple of folks quizzed me about this because you are speaking at this Paris gig Ian? We could check the list to see if there is wider interest? Cheers Colin

3 7

My schedule for the next few weeks
by Ian Glazer 09 Nov '16

09 Nov '16

Gang - Next week I can only make the 1st half hour of the DG call. The following week I can make neither the SC nor the DG call. i -- Ian Glazer Senior Director, Identity +1 202 255 3166 @iglazer <https://twitter.com/iglazer>

1 0

ID Pro DG meeting - slides
by Megan Cannon 09 Nov '16

09 Nov '16

Good morning, I added a couple of slides to our usual slide deck, and added the tinyurl for the attendance doc for today's meeting. Please let me know if you have any edits. All the best, Megan Megan Cannon | Program Manager | Virtual, Inc. D: +1.781.876.6287 | M: +1.781.258.5523 mcannon(a)virtualmgmt.com<mailto:mcannon@virtualmgmt.com> virtualmgmt.com <http://www.virtualmgmt.com/> | blog.virtualmgmt.com<http://blog.virtualmgmt.com/> 401 Edgewater Place, Suite 600, Wakefield, MA, 01880 USA [cid:image002.png@01CF8A44.EB615EF0]

1 0

Kantara: ID Pro SC Meeting Today 1pm ET
by Megan Cannon 07 Nov '16

07 Nov '16

Good Morning! I hope you all had a great weekend! Here is some review material for our meeting today at 1pm Eastern: Agenda: 1. Officer election results 2. Upcoming meeting agendas * Projects 3. Driving meeting participation * Data from past meetings 4. Certification __________________________________________________ 1. Officer elections - 49 out of 102 votes = 48% participation - great participation! * Vice Chair: Sarah Squire * Secretary: Andrew Hughes * Megan is happy to notify the nominees today, before the SC shares the results at the Wednesday meeting. 2. Wednesday's meeting agenda: * Officer election results * Review final 3 questions in #4 * Start conversation on teams i. Do we know what projects we are planning on? ii. Identify leaders for each team 1. Driving Meeting participation Here is some data about our participation so far: * 48% participation in voting - excellent * Attendance in meetings declined after the first call, but is leveling off. [cid:image004.png@01D238E7.6FDDBF90] * Participation via email threads: Question 2: Vision Statement - 6 comments by 4 users Question 3A: Future of the Org - 5 comments by 4 users Question 3B: Mission Statement - 15 comments by 10 users 11 total unique users over all three threads out of 102 people on the distro list = 11% participation. 1. Certification * Virtual has an excellent certification department - achieving a certification for Kantara may be less complicated than it seems. Happy to discuss! Thanks all, I look forward to speaking with you shortly! Best, Megan Megan Cannon | Program Manager | Virtual, Inc. D: +1.781.876.6287 | M: +1.781.258.5523 mcannon(a)virtualmgmt.com<mailto:mcannon@virtualmgmt.com> virtualmgmt.com <http://www.virtualmgmt.com/> | blog.virtualmgmt.com<http://blog.virtualmgmt.com/> 401 Edgewater Place, Suite 600, Wakefield, MA, 01880 USA [cid:image002.png@01CF8A44.EB615EF0]

3 2

Meeting notes from 2016-11-02 call
by Andrew Hughes 02 Nov '16

02 Nov '16

Good call today - good discussions on body of knowledge, certifications, library. Please remember to look for the ballot announcements for Vice-Chair & Secretary election. These were posted to the [DG-IDPRO] list. Ballots close November 4 @ 17:00 Eastern Time (i.e. New York local time). Notes are here: https://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/display/idpro/DRAFT+2016-11-02+Mee… *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

1 0

Tiny url for attendance?
by Ian Glazer 02 Nov '16

02 Nov '16

Do we have one for today? -- Ian Glazer Senior Director, Identity +1 202 255 3166 @iglazer <https://twitter.com/iglazer>

2 1

On a flight today
by Ian Glazer 31 Oct '16

31 Oct '16

I'll be in the air during our call (November is a travel heavy month) I don't have much for the group other than I am a little concerned about the size of the group - especially knowing that we are heading into November and will be splitting up into project teams Also did the ballot go out? i

5 6

Members of the DG?
by Ian Glazer 28 Oct '16

28 Oct '16

Gang - I am little concerned about the turnout to the DG meetings. How many people have signed up for the mailing list? -- Ian Glazer Senior Director, Identity +1 202 255 3166 @iglazer <https://twitter.com/iglazer>

2 1

Kantara ID Pro DG Officers Ballot
by Megan Cannon 27 Oct '16

27 Oct '16

Greetings, Please see the below preview of the voting ballot survey to go out to the membership. Please come back with any edits. Survey preview<https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/Preview/?sm=lzucJAYt1Y0mSGLx7S2sAgSC2wU4afzp…> Thank you, Megan Megan Cannon | Program Manager | Virtual, Inc. D: +1.781.876.6287 | M: +1.781.258.5523 mcannon(a)virtualmgmt.com<mailto:mcannon@virtualmgmt.com> virtualmgmt.com <http://www.virtualmgmt.com/> | blog.virtualmgmt.com<http://blog.virtualmgmt.com/> 401 Edgewater Place, Suite 600, Wakefield, MA, 01880 USA [cid:image002.png@01CF8A44.EB615EF0]

4 3

Fwd: Notes from Wednesday October 26 2016, session 2 10:30 - 11:30 room F
by Andrew Hughes 27 Oct '16

27 Oct '16

OK - email issues - here's the forwarded email with the embedded whiteboard picture/ andrew. *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security * ---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: Andrew Hughes <andrewhughes3000(a)gmail.com> Date: Wed, Oct 26, 2016 at 11:48 AM Subject: Notes from Wednesday October 26 2016, session 2 10:30 - 11:30 room F To: Internet Identity Workshop <iiwnotes(a)gmail.com> Cc: Colin Wallis <colin(a)kantarainitiative.org>, "andrewhughes3000(a)gmail.com" <andrewhughes3000(a)gmail.com> Conveyor & Notes: AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com Wednesday October 26, 2016 Session 2, Room F 10:30 - 11:30 ID Professional Association - introduction and overview Kantara Initiative is incubating the formation of a new ID Professionals Association. The group discussed what the association intends to be, common body of knowledge, who members might be, and current timelines. Pre-formation meetings are happening weekly as a Kantara Initiative Discussion Group. We expect to have announcements ready in February 2017. The whiteboard picture captures the topics discussed. -- *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

1 0

Fwd: Notes from Wednesday October 26 2016, session 2 10:30 - 11:30 room F
by Andrew Hughes 26 Oct '16

26 Oct '16

FYI - notes from my ID Pro session at IIW. It's one way to represent what a group of pros might consider for an association. Andrew. -- *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

1 0

Comments from GTM
by Megan Cannon 26 Oct '16

26 Oct '16

Hello Andrew - here are the comments from GTM if you need them. Thanks! Megan 12:01 PM Me Greetings! Please mark your attendance here: http://tinyurl.com/zlr2gkj 12:02 PM Patrick Essien<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20111%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207274508%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Greetings All! 12:06 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Hi all from Belgium! Mic problems so will just comments here in chat. 12:09 PM Andrew Hindle<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20115%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207536652%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> I do.... 12:09 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Does IAM industry suffcientely cover our intended member base? 12:11 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Andrew H +1 12:11 PM Colin Wallis<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20117%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207667724%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> OPenstand Principles here: https://open-stand.org/about-us/principles/ 12:11 PM Catherine Schulten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20110%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207208972%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> for example this non-discriminatory list excludes people with physical handicaps 12:11 PM Thorsten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20105%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206881292%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> +1 from me as well. 'everyone' might be enough 12:12 PM Colin Wallis<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20117%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207667724%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> And linked directly off Kantara's principles here:https://kantarainitiative.org/about/principles/ 12:12 PM Colin Wallis<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20117%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207667724%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> try that again.. https://kantarainitiative.org/about/principles/ 12:14 PM Andrew Hindle<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20115%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207536652%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Body of Knowlege, or Body of Work? 12:16 PM Thorsten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20105%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206881292%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> even though that is a list as well, its not that problematic than the first one. even if something is missed, its not discrimanatory 12:16 PM Colin Wallis<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20117%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207667724%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Both? 12:16 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Guess best current practive is embedded in body of knowledge, so agree. 12:17 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Mic problems... 12:18 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Or, just strike 'body of knowledge' from the phrase - 12:18 PM Thorsten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20105%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206881292%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> but best practise is not equal body of work? 12:18 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> if the sentence is deonstructed "to teach... best current practice... to the relevant... 12:18 PM Andrew Hindle<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20115%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207536652%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Do we need to call out the importance of 'keeping up to date'? 12:19 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Guess the word 'current' implies it's up-to-date. 12:21 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> yes 12:25 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Valid point; but guess we need to start somewhere and assume this list of priorities could change through time? 12:26 PM kendagg<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20102%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206684684%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> to me agree with andrew Reply in private<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20102%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206684684%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> 12:26 PM kendagg<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20102%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206684684%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> agree with andrew 12:28 PM Thorsten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20105%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206881292%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> I am sorry, have to leave in a few minutes. Eager to hear/see the recordings. bye 12:29 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> i've got one - last in line please 12:31 PM kendagg<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20102%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206684684%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> i've got a comment 12:35 PM Andrew Hindle<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20115%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207536652%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> To add.... 12:36 PM Catherine Schulten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20110%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207208972%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> also some of the standards reflect the vision of a specific industry sector and doesn't apply to all 12:36 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Agree with Collin; contribution to standards which just cross our landscape like gov, finance, etc; not really on core standards inside our practice. 12:37 PM kendagg<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20102%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206684684%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> agree wholeheartedly with colin and andrewh 12:38 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> ian 12:38 PM kendagg<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20102%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206684684%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> agree with Catherine --- rationale for advocacy to that sector --- advocacy is a two way street 12:39 PM Colin Wallis<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20117%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207667724%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> in the queue for a brief comment plse. 12:42 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Reminder: Please mark your attendance here: http://tinyurl.com/zlr2gkj 12:43 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> a shibboleth 12:44 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> letting others speak 12:44 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> what works in other orgs? 12:44 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> yes and also no 12:45 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Agree; think we need both; open and closed. 12:45 PM Catherine Schulten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20110%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207208972%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> also agree open and closed 12:45 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> i agree with A.H. 12:46 PM Catherine Schulten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20110%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207208972%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> vendors are in the trenches also 12:46 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Yes; mixed; that's providing value. 12:47 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> forum rules of conduct... 12:47 PM Yaliman, Mehmet<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20109%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207143436%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> no cold calls based on forum contribution 12:47 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> i agree with ah 12:47 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> other associations have "vendor and marketing' channels 12:47 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> that are specifically to advertise to ourselves 12:48 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> yup 12:48 PM Dobbs, George<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20118%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207733260%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Users may be more comfortable with openness than vendors might be. Some sort of rules / moderation probably needed. 12:48 PM Andrew Hindle<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20115%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207536652%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> That was Catherine's point. But I do agree with it :) 12:48 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Agree with keeping out commercial motivations; but strongly believe mixed and open dialogue is were the value comes from. 12:50 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Modification: commercial motivations are valuable - it's being respectful of the channel 12:50 PM Andrew Hughes<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20106%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%206946828%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> respectful is critical 12:52 PM Chris Adriaensen<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20114%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207471116%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Both online and in-person are needed I feel. 12:52 PM Catherine Schulten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20110%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207208972%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> i personally like co-located events with a breakout for the professional group to meet in person 12:53 PM Catherine Schulten<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20110%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207208972%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> IDESG Plenary, Gartner IAM forum for example 12:54 PM Andrew Hindle<res://\\G2MResource_en.dll/%3cA%20HREF=%22%3conLeftClick%3eeCMD_SetChatTo%20115%3c/onLeftClick%3e%3conRightClick%3eeCMD_DoAttendeeContextMenu%207536652%3c/onRightClick%3e%22%3e%3c/A%3e> Thank you Ian :) Megan Cannon | Program Manager | Virtual, Inc. D: +1.781.876.6287 | M: +1.781.258.5523 mcannon(a)virtualmgmt.com<mailto:mcannon@virtualmgmt.com> virtualmgmt.com <http://www.virtualmgmt.com/> | blog.virtualmgmt.com<http://blog.virtualmgmt.com/> 401 Edgewater Place, Suite 600, Wakefield, MA, 01880 USA [cid:image002.png@01CF8A44.EB615EF0]

1 0

Link to the Roll document
by Andrew Hughes 26 Oct '16

26 Oct '16

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1emURSIK-yA5GisFwXNdAZE5GwLN7b0MoFevDdVr… Hi - here's the Edit link for today's roll call doc. Shannon - could you please shorten the link and put it onto the cover page of today's deck? I'll be taking notes again today - but won't be able to talk as much today. thanks andrew. *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

3 4

Today's meeting
by Ian Glazer 26 Oct '16

26 Oct '16

Hi everyone - Sorry but I won't be able to make it. Talk on Wednesday. i

4 13

Deletion of 2016-10-12 IDPro recording
by Andrew Hughes 19 Oct '16

19 Oct '16

Hi all - I'm going to delete the recording of last week's call from the ID Pro wiki andrew. *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

2 2

Roll Call google doc is now ready
by Andrew Hughes 19 Oct '16

19 Oct '16

I've populated today's roll call doc with the current list of email subscribers. andrew. *Andrew Hughes *CISM CISSP Independent Consultant *In Turn Information Management Consulting* o +1 650.209.7542 m +1 250.888.9474 1249 Palmer Road, Victoria, BC V8P 2H8 AndrewHughes3000(a)gmail.com ca.linkedin.com/pub/andrew-hughes/a/58/682/ *Identity Management | IT Governance | Information Security *

2 3

Kantara ID Pro Nominations as of Oct 17
by Shannon Taylor 17 Oct '16

17 Oct '16

All, Attached are the current nominations received to date for the ID Pro Discussion Group. I saw in the notes from today's meeting that we don't want/need to market this to heavily now - as we have nominees for both positions. I can send out a final note tomorrow and indicate last call and also note that if you sent a nomination and did not receive a confirmation email to resend. I want to be sure we didn't miss anyone thru spam etc. Please let me know if you have any questions. Regards, Shannon

2 1

Content for meeting notice for 2016-10-19 IDPro call
by Andrew Hughes 17 Oct '16

17 Oct '16

How does this look for sending out to the DG-IDPro list. Also, the link to the blank roll call document is below. I will populate the names list closer to meeting time - but the link works now. https://docs.google.com/document/d/18cPQlnm4oFp-xYHngyxNFaPGwQYASHuAXWm4eDC… ------- Greetings, The next meeting of the Kantara ID Pro Discussion Group is *Wednesday, October 19 at 12:00pm Eastern Daylight Time (UTC -4h)*. The general agenda: - Reminder of call for nominations deadline for Vice-Chair and Secretary elections - Discussion of responses to survey questions 1-4 (Principles, Vision, Mission, Interest areas) Note that the discussion of the survey responses is anticipated to take 2-3 meetings. The meeting will be conducted via GoToMeeting, the details are below and attached is an entry for your calendar. For those that cannot join, the meeting will be recorded and posted in the Kantara ID Pro wiki for a period of seven days prior to being deleted. We intend to follow this recording procedure until the first meeting with an elected Secretary. Please don’t hesitate to reach out with any questions. Regards, Shannon Taylor

3 4