Hi all, Today is our (Sarah and my) last full day in France so I will not make the call today. https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87282263538pwd=K0RwY1g1b3pKeHdBcXpjeExVZUFpQT09 I suggest that we focus on reviewing the TPI document and consider the extent to which we include a code of conduct directly in the document and/or reference it, and/or create this as a separate document. I would also like to have the workgroup voice its opinion on a name change to Anchored Notice and Consent Receipts WG. Mark, and Sharon have already expressed their support as do I so this is a majority of voting members but it would be great to be unanimous on this. We can do this by replying to this thread. I have reviewed this with Alec Laws (LC Chair) and we can get Kantara IT to go through the web pages to make the changes if all agree. I meant to produce a word doc of the TPI document to share for edits but ran into some formatting issues… https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/WA/pages/82542593/Transparency+Per... I would like the call to stay focused on this, I believe this document is very close to a release and my suggestion is to review this document on the call and live edit the wiki. I have queued up Kantara support for the publication once we have a final draft. I hope this finds everyone well, that the fires in Canada are not too severely affecting people. From my US perspective, the 4th of July is a much more mixed set of emotions that growing up. All the more reason for us to work to create the digital freedom that our publications, and technology here can enable. Best regards, Sal
Hi Sal (et al) Thanks for this, I have gone ahead and re-arranged the work, as discussed, splitting TPI’s and Consent Receipt v2 out into two over arching Road Map items -TPI’s covering conformity assessment and the Consent Receipt V2; covering Digital Consent component. Please review so that we can schedule meeting and spec editing topics. Best, Mark The editorial proposal for the roadmap ( ANCR Spécification Editorial Roadmap Proposal still missing the AuthC * Transparency Performance Indicators * Used to Measure the performance of a PII Controller's digital privacy and security transparency * Measuring how operable transparency and accountability is, in context of digital identifier management services, * TPI - Operational Transparency Assessment Framework * Transparency Code of Conduct * Mapping TPI’s to Convention 108+ transparency requirements * Risk Assurance Framework * 3 Vectors of Data Governance Risk Assurance * 4 Levels of Transparency Assurance Consent Receipt v2: Digital Consent Outline (components already in draft separately) * Two Factor Concentric Notice for generating notice receipts * Primary Consent Types - Expanded with * Direct Consent * Altruistic Consent * Secondary Consent, for any of the 6 legal justifications * Implied consent for secondary purposes * Specifying a purpose * For any legal justification * For Primary Consent * For Secondary Consent * Permission for secondary purpose * For Consent Types * Binding Permissions to a purpose * Permission log * Operational Transparency * Differential Transparency Signalling for managing privacy expectations * Privacy as Expected the Consent Gateway * AuthC authorization from consent, notice, notification and disclosure protocol * dialogue protocol, for informed consent * directed consent : consent as a currency an exchange protocol * Notice & Consent Receipt Exchange Protocol * Digital Consent - Notice receipt and consent token - * PII Controller Notice Record and Credential for generating and anchoring notice and consent receipts * Layered Notice Signalling * Credential, rights, statements, required info, and policy * Use Cases * W3C DNT Extension for digital consent * Transparency Index * Private AI On Jul 5, 2023, at 2:19 AM, Salvatore D'Agostino <1dmach1n35@gmail.com> wrote: Hi all, Today is our (Sarah and my) last full day in France so I will not make the call today. https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87282263538pwd=K0RwY1g1b3pKeHdBcXpjeExVZUFpQT09 I suggest that we focus on reviewing the TPI document and consider the extent to which we include a code of conduct directly in the document and/or reference it, and/or create this as a separate document. I would also like to have the workgroup voice its opinion on a name change to Anchored Notice and Consent Receipts WG. Mark, and Sharon have already expressed their support as do I so this is a majority of voting members but it would be great to be unanimous on this. We can do this by replying to this thread. I have reviewed this with Alec Laws (LC Chair) and we can get Kantara IT to go through the web pages to make the changes if all agree. I meant to produce a word doc of the TPI document to share for edits but ran into some formatting issues… https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/WA/pages/82542593/Transparency+Per... I would like the call to stay focused on this, I believe this document is very close to a release and my suggestion is to review this document on the call and live edit the wiki. I have queued up Kantara support for the publication once we have a final draft. I hope this finds everyone well, that the fires in Canada are not too severely affecting people. From my US perspective, the 4th of July is a much more mixed set of emotions that growing up. All the more reason for us to work to create the digital freedom that our publications, and technology here can enable. Best regards, Sal _______________________________________________ Wg-ancr mailing list -- wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org To unsubscribe send an email to wg-ancr-leave@kantarainitiative.org
Dear Mark, Spot on for roadmap. Please love to hear from WG. Really helpful to separate TPIs and CRv2. The roadmap ordering shows the relationship and relevance of the TPIs for a PII Controller. We can put to work immediately the TPIs as conformance tools for transparency assurance levels and introduce the vectors of governance apart from data protection, and improve data security in the process. Thanks for decades of work here. Very best, Sal PS In parallel, need to emphasize how the receipts are for people where they control the exchange of currency, as part of the narrative as well as clean the details in the spec weeds. From: MarkL <mark@0pn.org> Sent: Wednesday, July 5, 2023 11:28 AM To: Salvatore D'Agostino <1dmach1n35@gmail.com> Cc: g.agassini@yahoo.com; wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org Subject: [WG-ANCR] Re: Call Hi Sal (et al) Thanks for this, I have gone ahead and re-arranged the work, as discussed, splitting TPI’s and Consent Receipt v2 out into two over arching Road Map items -TPI’s covering conformity assessment and the Consent Receipt V2; covering Digital Consent component. Please review so that we can schedule meeting and spec editing topics. Best, Mark The editorial proposal for the roadmap ( ANCR Spécification Editorial Roadmap Proposal still missing the AuthC * Transparency Performance Indicators * Used to Measure the performance of a PII Controller's digital privacy and security transparency * Measuring how operable transparency and accountability is, in context of digital identifier management services, * TPI - Operational Transparency Assessment Framework * Transparency Code of Conduct * Mapping TPI’s to Convention 108+ transparency requirements * Risk Assurance Framework * 3 Vectors of Data Governance Risk Assurance * 4 Levels of Transparency Assurance Consent Receipt v2: Digital Consent Outline (components already in draft separately) * Two Factor Concentric Notice for generating notice receipts * Primary Consent Types - Expanded with * Direct Consent * Altruistic Consent * Secondary Consent, for any of the 6 legal justifications * Implied consent for secondary purposes * Specifying a purpose * For any legal justification * For Primary Consent * For Secondary Consent * Permission for secondary purpose * For Consent Types * Binding Permissions to a purpose * Permission log * Operational Transparency * Differential Transparency Signaling for managing privacy expectations * Privacy as Expected the Consent Gateway * AuthC authorization from consent, notice, notification and disclosure protocol dialogue protocol, for informed consent * directed consent : consent as a currency an exchange protocol * Notice & Consent Receipt Exchange Protocol * Digital Consent - Notice receipt and consent token - * PII Controller Notice Record and Credential for generating and anchoring notice and consent receipts * Layered Notice Signalling * Credential, rights, statements, required info, and policy * Use Cases * W3C DNT Extension for digital consent * Transparency Index * Private AI On Jul 5, 2023, at 2:19 AM, Salvatore D'Agostino <1dmach1n35@gmail.com <mailto:1dmach1n35@gmail.com> > wrote: Hi all, Today is our (Sarah and my) last full day in France so I will not make the call today. https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87282263538pwd=K0RwY1g1b3pKeHdBcXpjeExVZUFpQT09 I suggest that we focus on reviewing the TPI document and consider the extent to which we include a code of conduct directly in the document and/or reference it, and/or create this as a separate document. I would also like to have the workgroup voice its opinion on a name change to Anchored Notice and Consent Receipts WG. Mark, and Sharon have already expressed their support as do I so this is a majority of voting members but it would be great to be unanimous on this. We can do this by replying to this thread. I have reviewed this with Alec Laws (LC Chair) and we can get Kantara IT to go through the web pages to make the changes if all agree. I meant to produce a word doc of the TPI document to share for edits but ran into some formatting issues… https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/WA/pages/82542593/Transparency+Per... I would like the call to stay focused on this, I believe this document is very close to a release and my suggestion is to review this document on the call and live edit the wiki. I have queued up Kantara support for the publication once we have a final draft. I hope this finds everyone well, that the fires in Canada are not too severely affecting people. From my US perspective, the 4th of July is a much more mixed set of emotions that growing up. All the more reason for us to work to create the digital freedom that our publications, and technology here can enable. Best regards, Sal _______________________________________________ Wg-ancr mailing list -- wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org <mailto:wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org> To unsubscribe send an email to wg-ancr-leave@kantarainitiative.org <mailto:wg-ancr-leave@kantarainitiative.org>
Hi All, Call reminder today 12 EST. https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87282263538?pwd=K0RwY1g1b3pKeHdBcXpjeExVZUFpQT09 I forwarded this message as it captures our roadmap (see agenda discussion item) and the need to complete the TPIs (primary agenda item). https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/WA/pages/82542593/Transparency+Performance+Indicator+s+TPI+s+v0.8’ Agenda: Roll IPR Agenda Approval TPIs Inclusion of Code of Conduct Items to complete TPI 1.0 Engagement CAN/NGI CA NIST Roadmap and CRv2 Brief discussion WG Admin WG Name Change Every voting member but <mailto:paul.knowles@humancolossus.org> @Paul Knowles has approved the name change so it goes ahead (Paul you can still chime in..) Election of Gigi as WG Secretary Any other business. Best, Sal PS Gigi can you confirm listserve is working for you. From: Salvatore D'Agostino Sent: Monday, July 10, 2023 8:24 AM To: MarkL <mark@0pn.org>; Salvatore D'Agostino <1dmach1n35@gmail.com> Cc: g.agassini@yahoo.com; wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org Subject: RE: [WG-ANCR] Re: Call Dear Mark, Spot on for roadmap. Please love to hear from WG. Really helpful to separate TPIs and CRv2. The roadmap ordering shows the relationship and relevance of the TPIs for a PII Controller. We can put to work immediately the TPIs as conformance tools for transparency assurance levels and introduce the vectors of governance apart from data protection, and improve data security in the process. Thanks for decades of work here. Very best, Sal PS In parallel, need to emphasize how the receipts are for people where they control the exchange of currency, as part of the narrative as well as clean the details in the spec weeds. From: MarkL <mark@0pn.org <mailto:mark@0pn.org> > Sent: Wednesday, July 5, 2023 11:28 AM To: Salvatore D'Agostino <1dmach1n35@gmail.com <mailto:1dmach1n35@gmail.com> > Cc: g.agassini@yahoo.com <mailto:g.agassini@yahoo.com> ; wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org <mailto:wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org> Subject: [WG-ANCR] Re: Call Hi Sal (et al) Thanks for this, I have gone ahead and re-arranged the work, as discussed, splitting TPI’s and Consent Receipt v2 out into two over arching Road Map items -TPI’s covering conformity assessment and the Consent Receipt V2; covering Digital Consent component. Please review so that we can schedule meeting and spec editing topics. Best, Mark The editorial proposal for the roadmap ( ANCR Spécification Editorial Roadmap Proposal still missing the AuthC * Transparency Performance Indicators * Used to Measure the performance of a PII Controller's digital privacy and security transparency * Measuring how operable transparency and accountability is, in context of digital identifier management services, * TPI - Operational Transparency Assessment Framework * Transparency Code of Conduct * Mapping TPI’s to Convention 108+ transparency requirements * Risk Assurance Framework * 3 Vectors of Data Governance Risk Assurance * 4 Levels of Transparency Assurance Consent Receipt v2: Digital Consent Outline (components already in draft separately) * Two Factor Concentric Notice for generating notice receipts * Primary Consent Types - Expanded with * Direct Consent * Altruistic Consent * Secondary Consent, for any of the 6 legal justifications * Implied consent for secondary purposes * Specifying a purpose * For any legal justification * For Primary Consent * For Secondary Consent * Permission for secondary purpose * For Consent Types * Binding Permissions to a purpose * Permission log * Operational Transparency * Differential Transparency Signaling for managing privacy expectations * Privacy as Expected the Consent Gateway * AuthC authorization from consent, notice, notification and disclosure protocol dialogue protocol, for informed consent * directed consent : consent as a currency an exchange protocol * Notice & Consent Receipt Exchange Protocol * Digital Consent - Notice receipt and consent token - * PII Controller Notice Record and Credential for generating and anchoring notice and consent receipts * Layered Notice Signalling * Credential, rights, statements, required info, and policy * Use Cases * W3C DNT Extension for digital consent * Transparency Index * Private AI On Jul 5, 2023, at 2:19 AM, Salvatore D'Agostino <1dmach1n35@gmail.com <mailto:1dmach1n35@gmail.com> > wrote: Hi all, Today is our (Sarah and my) last full day in France so I will not make the call today. https://us06web.zoom.us/j/87282263538pwd=K0RwY1g1b3pKeHdBcXpjeExVZUFpQT09 I suggest that we focus on reviewing the TPI document and consider the extent to which we include a code of conduct directly in the document and/or reference it, and/or create this as a separate document. I would also like to have the workgroup voice its opinion on a name change to Anchored Notice and Consent Receipts WG. Mark, and Sharon have already expressed their support as do I so this is a majority of voting members but it would be great to be unanimous on this. We can do this by replying to this thread. I have reviewed this with Alec Laws (LC Chair) and we can get Kantara IT to go through the web pages to make the changes if all agree. I meant to produce a word doc of the TPI document to share for edits but ran into some formatting issues… https://kantara.atlassian.net/wiki/spaces/WA/pages/82542593/Transparency+Per... I would like the call to stay focused on this, I believe this document is very close to a release and my suggestion is to review this document on the call and live edit the wiki. I have queued up Kantara support for the publication once we have a final draft. I hope this finds everyone well, that the fires in Canada are not too severely affecting people. From my US perspective, the 4th of July is a much more mixed set of emotions that growing up. All the more reason for us to work to create the digital freedom that our publications, and technology here can enable. Best regards, Sal _______________________________________________ Wg-ancr mailing list -- wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org <mailto:wg-ancr@kantarainitiative.org> To unsubscribe send an email to wg-ancr-leave@kantarainitiative.org <mailto:wg-ancr-leave@kantarainitiative.org>
participants (3)
-
MarkL -
Salvatore D'Agostino -
Salvatore D'Agostino