- DG-AM - mailman.kantarainitiative.org

e-Vote: closing the AMDG
by Heather Flanagan 03 Oct '12

03 Oct '12

Hello Attribute Management Discussion Group members, The AMDG is conducting an e-vote to close the Attribute Management Discussion Group, as the deliverables from our charter have been met. Please submit your vote of YES or NO to staff(a)kantarainitiative.org. ___ YES ___ NO (provide comment on rationale to assist please) Please include in your SUBJECT line "AMDG closure." The voting will be open until 17:00 PT Tuesday, 02 October 2012. If you have any questions on this process, please do not hesitate to contact staff (at) kantarainitiative (dot) org. Heather Flanagan Secretary, AMDG

6 6

Notes from today's LC call re: the proposed Attribute Management WG
by Heather Flanagan 25 Sep '12

25 Sep '12

Hello all - The LC met today and, among other things, discussed the proposed Attribute Management Work Group charter. Below are the notes from that discussion. To summarize: some further wordsmithing is desired and one person has stepped forward to help sponsor the charter through the process, though 3 sponsors, including 2 Members, are required for the formation of a new WG. Proposed Charter - Attribute Management Work Group The AMDG has published their report, had a number of next steps discussion, there is work to do beyond what would be in the scope of a DG, so it is likely time to form a WG Two paths identified: an ongoing landscape review; more active component around Framework Definition and Best Practice around an attribute broker model and the certification - not how to exchange or build trust, but how to verify attributes and what is appropriate for those exchanges; basically attributes as a component of compliance; so this group would be reaching out to a broad range of stakeholders to liaise with them (OASIS for the Trust Elevation, OIX for the Exchange, etc) One comment received: better positioned as a Creative Commons IPR policy not a PC and RAND IPR Discussion (ColinW) is this too non specific or should it tie more tightly with some of the other groups working in this space? email response back is that the positioning is right because it is not overlapping and is adjacent enough; note that the verbal explanation is more clear than what is written; there should be an allowance for word-smithing of the charter but otherwise supportive of this moving forward (will have his name on it as a proposer) Call for other proposers? none on this call (no discussion) At this point, I think the DG group work is pretty much done and we should consider a vote to close the group. Other thoughts? The proposed charter is available online: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/x/GAGgAw -Heather

4 7

AMDG call today CANCELLED
by Heather Flanagan 11 Sep '12

11 Sep '12

Hello all - The Leadership Council has not had a chance to further discuss the Work Group charter. That should be high on the list for this week's call. We will be cancelling the AMDG meeting pending that conversation in the LC. -Heather

1 0

AMDG telecon CANCELED for 28-Aug-2012
by Heather Flanagan 25 Aug '12

25 Aug '12

Hi all - On our call on 21-August, we planned to discuss the potential WG charter and our general concerns about the attribute management work fits/overlaps in other WG with the Leadership Council on 22-August. Unfortunately, the LC didn't get to that topic on the agenda, so the next opportunity for that LC discussion is 29-August. With the results of that discussion our next big agenda item, that doesn't leave much for this Tuesday. So, the call this week is cancelled. Our next call will be 11-September. Please let me know if you have any questions! -Heather

1 0

REMINDER & AGENDA, AMDG telecon 21-Aug-2012 (Off-Week Call)
by Heather Flanagan 21 Aug '12

21 Aug '12

Hi all - The full agenda is available online: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/x/HACgAw Date and Time Date: Tuesday, 21 / 08 / 2012 Time: 11h PT / 14h ET / 19h UTC Dial in: PREFERRED: Skype: +99051000000481 IF NECESSARY: US Dial-In: +1-805-309-2350 | Room Code: 613-2898 AGENDA: Administrative Roll Call New member introduction - no new members Agenda confirmation Approval of Minutes: AMDG Meeting Notes 2012-06-05 Action item review Discussion Report from mini-F2F (Keith) Working Group Charter - move forward?

1 1

Background materials on AMDG from Kantara face-to-face
by Keith Hazelton 21 Aug '12

21 Aug '12

Folks, Here are a couple items from the Kantara F2F on the Attribute Management Discussion Group: Attached is a short powerpoint I presented on the AMDG work past & proposed. Please also see the list of attribute management issues that got some discussion as well: http://kantarainitiative.org/confluence/display/AMDG/Selected+Attribute+Man…

1 0

Meeting for today CANCELED
by Heather Flanagan 14 Aug '12

14 Aug '12

Hi all - Just to make sure we're officially official, this is a notice that the Attribute Management Discussion Group call today is cancelled. We will have an off-week call next week to catch up on the charter and the F2F. Thanks! -Heather

1 0

this week
by Salvatore D'Agostino 13 Aug '12

13 Aug '12

Hi all, I am on vacation, so I won't be able to make a call this week. Also given the NSTIC meeting in Chicago, I wonder if the rest of the group is up for a call? Regards, Sal Salvatore D'Agostino, CSCIP IDmachines LLC |1264 Beacon Street, #5 | Brookline, MA 02446 | USA http:\\www.idmachines.com <http://www.idmachines.com/> | http:\\idmachines.blogspot.com <http://idmachines.blogspot.com/> | @idmachines +1 617.201.4809 ph | +1 617.812.6495 fax

3 3

an Attribute Registry Requirements gathering exercise
by Heather Flanagan 02 Aug '12

02 Aug '12

Hi all - So, wearing my I2/ISOC hats, I would like to bring your attention to a requirements draft for an attribute registry: http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-johansson-areg-reqs-00 Leif Johansson and I put this together as one of the outputs from the last Attribute Workshop hosted by the Internet Society earlier this year. We would very much like your comments and feedback on the document, and encourage send Leif or I any comments, suggestions, or questions you might have. You can email the authors by clicking on the "Email" link at the top of the drafts page. Please forward this on to any other groups you think might be interested! -Heather Flanagan

4 5

Fwd: LoA registry update
by Heather Flanagan 01 Aug '12

01 Aug '12

And since we're talking about interesting new documents... This one will be added to the Repository after it makes it through the RFC Ed queue and has a number and permanent link. -Heather -------- Original Message -------- Subject: LoA registry update Date: Thu, 02 Aug 2012 00:59:59 +0200 From: Leif Johansson <leifj(a)sunet.se> To: WG-FI(a)kantarainitiative.org, John Bradley <ve7jtb(a)ve7jtb.com>, Ann West <awest(a)internet2.edu>, Renee Shuey <rshuey(a)psu.edu>, Elisabeth Dellkrantz <elisabeth.dellkrantz(a)elegnamnden.se>, Stefan Santesson <stefan(a)aaa-sec.com>, Fredrik Ljunggren <fredrik(a)kirei.se>, Hörbe Rainer <rainer(a)hoerbe.at>, Valter Nordh <valter.nordh(a)gu.se>, Peter Schober <peter.schober(a)univie.ac.at>, Joni Brennan <joni(a)ieee-isto.org>, Heather Flanagan <flanagan(a)isoc.org> The LOA registry [1] has now entered the RFC editors queue. The registry has been created by IANA (empty) already but isn't active until the RFC number has been allocated. This is now a matter of weeks probably. As soon as the IESG has allocated the designated pool of experts I propose to organize an online event where we can start to craft the initial registrations that should probably go into the registry soon thereafter. - InCommon silver+bronze (2 registrations) - Kantara IAF loa1-4 (4 registrations) - OIX FICAM LOA1 (1 registration) - ISO29115 levels (not sure who to go-to for this...) Then there are a bunch of stuff where I don't have good contact but I've included those I have for things like... - FICAM LoA 1-3 (probably 3 registrations??) - ?Stork? - SE govt ALs ? - ?Austrian govt? - ?edugain? Anyway, my idea was to do a few of the "big ones" in a single "sitting" to share knowledge and get the registry populated. Cheers Leif [1] http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-johansson-loa-registry-06

3 2